I liked FEAR. Sure, the endless "office cubicles and mechs" stuff became a little tiresome, but I enjoyed the fusion of western FPS and J-Horror sensibilities. I only play games to experience immersive or otherwise interesting stories, themes and settings. Gameplay isn't very important to me.
Deus Ex was also pretty good. Same goes for Thief 2.
Deus Ex was also pretty good. Same goes for Thief 2.