Dumb question

That's because in your ReadHS() function, you loop through the FileMemoryList, storing the object in i, but then printing the contents of filestore.

	For Local i:TFileMemory = EachIn FileMemoryList
			'Print "High Score: "+filestore.initals+" "+filestore.points+" Points" change to
	
			Print "High Score: "+i.initals+" "+i.points+" Points"
		Next

Also there is another bug in your ReadHS() and RemoveHS() routine. You read in the highscore list and add it to the end of the already filled list. You need to do a FileMemoryList.Clear() at the start of the functions to erase the contents.