That game does not, in any way whatsoever, follow his game design.
His game proposal says little really, and it certainly doesn't say anything about the game being peaceful (just the opposite.) I agree that this game isn't what he had in mind, but it does in fact follow his proposal to the letter.
The fact is he has little grasp of what makes a game, and thus his proposal could be fulfilled with a simple re-skin of just about any existing game.