While I am a great fan of adventure games (played pretty much every one under the sun), I've found the 3D ones to be a lot less immersive than the good old 2D ones.
For example, Monkey Island 3 beats Monkey Island 4 hands down. A lot of the interesting cartoony look & feel with distorted perspective used by many adventures doesn't translate well to 3D, and attempts to create this just looks a bit shoddy... And if you don't it tends to look too sterile -- either way it's a tough job to create the same kind of atmosphere in 3D as it is in 2D I think...
(That said, the more adventure games the better!)
For example, Monkey Island 3 beats Monkey Island 4 hands down. A lot of the interesting cartoony look & feel with distorted perspective used by many adventures doesn't translate well to 3D, and attempts to create this just looks a bit shoddy... And if you don't it tends to look too sterile -- either way it's a tough job to create the same kind of atmosphere in 3D as it is in 2D I think...
(That said, the more adventure games the better!)